Saint Martin Parish Sheriff's officials say they arrested 17-year-old David Sylvester of Breaux Bridge in connection with the stolen ATV's reported Wednesday.
He was charged with a number of offenses including theft over $1,000 and simple burglary.
Two ATV's were also recovered
Investigators say the suspects stole four ATV's from homes along Anse Broussard Road.
Wednesday's manhunt focused on fields along I-10 between Breaux Bridge and Lafayette.
Authorities are still searching for the remaining suspects.
They are believed to be unarmed, but homeowners are advised to be cautious.